Listen to blog post
Your Grill, Your Rules
It’s a warm Saturday afternoon—the kind where the scent of charcoal hangs in the air and neighbors start peeking over fences to see what’s sizzling. You’re standing in front of your grill, tongs in one hand, a cold drink in the other, staring down at two cuts of meat on the prep table. On one side: a tray of glistening chicken leg quarters, marinated overnight in a smoky citrus blend. On the other: thick, boneless New York strip steaks, perfectly trimmed and ready for a serious sear.
You’ve got a decision to make.
The Classic Crowd-Pleaser
There’s something timeless about chicken leg quarters. They’re hearty, flavorful, and they let everyone know you’re not just grilling—you’re putting in work. These cuts don’t just get slapped over fire—they get the royal treatment. Low and slow over indirect heat, soaking up every bit of smoke like they were made for it.
You seasoned yours with a bold rub—heavy on paprika, garlic, and just a whisper of cayenne. You laid them skin-side up, away from the flames, and closed the lid. That’s the trick: patience. About 45 minutes later, you slid them over the hot coals just long enough to crisp the skin to a crackling finish.
When you lifted the lid again, that smoky aroma hit you like a wave of backyard barbecues past. These aren’t just leg quarters—they’re statements. They say, “Sit down, stay awhile.”
The Sizzle of Steak
But then there are the steaks. Those boneless New York strips sit there like Ferraris in the garage—sleek, powerful, and begging to be unleashed. You keep it simple: coarse salt, cracked black pepper, and a light coat of oil. These steaks don’t need a lot. They speak for themselves.
You fire up the grill, get it screaming hot, and drop the first steak. The hiss it makes? That’s the sound you live for. Four minutes per side, no more, no less. That sear locks in the juices and gives the outside that rich, beefy crust that only fire can create.
You let them rest under foil for a few minutes, the juices redistributing like a sigh of relief. Then you slice—clean through to a perfect pink center. One bite, and you remember why steak is always a contender: bold, buttery, luxurious.
So… Who Wins?
That night, you serve both. The chicken leg quarters go fast—bones picked clean, smoke-kissed skin devoured. But the strip steaks? They quiet the crowd. People pause with each bite, chewing slowly, nodding in quiet appreciation.
The truth? There’s no clear winner.
If you’ve got time, good company, and a cooler full of drinks, chicken leg quarters are your best friend. They turn grilling into an event.
But when you’re chasing that flawless sear and a plate that says “steak night,” the New York strip is king.
Grillmaster’s Wisdom
Here’s the move: don’t choose. Do both. Start your cook with the leg quarters—let the smoke do its thing—then finish strong with steaks that sear in minutes. It’s the perfect balance of patience and payoff.
And if your neighbors start wandering over with empty plates? Well, that’s just the price of being the grillmaster everyone’s watching.
Want the go-to marinade for your leg quarters? Or the butter blend that turns a good strip steak into perfection? Just ask—you’ll be keeping the coals warm anyway.
